DECORATED VEILS

Baroness Alianor (Aliyah) bat Asriel Society for Creative Anachronism (SCA)


Email: TheKissingCamels@gmail.com   Middle Kingdom - Pentamere - North Woods - Wealdlake

Table of Contents

Introduction

My interest in decorated veils was just cursory and fleeting at first. In my early years in the SCA, the beaded veils I saw at events were few and usually worn by someone, well, "of importance." Then, at a Silent Auction fundraiser at a holiday party for my SCA Household, House Ironwolf, I fell in love. Mistress Jervisa Wainwright had made and donated to the auction a linen veil beaded in glass and silver. It had that je-ne-sais-quoi. Unfortunately, I lost the bid. Shortly after the holidays I learned I was to have the honor of serving as the Baroness of North Woods, a Barony of the Middle Kingdom (Mid-Michigan). I contacted Mistress Jervisa and asked if I could commission her to make such a veil for me using Baronial colors. I was deeply moved when she gifted that veil to me for my Installation as Baroness. Thus began my trip down the rabbit hole of decorated veils. It is not just the bling, but the added weight creates a look, a movement, and feel that I absolutely adore.

Evidence for Decorated Veils in the Middle Ages

The Cathedral of Chartres, built around 1145-1150, stands out for the extreme quality of its sculptures. At the right-hand door of the Royal Portal there is a statue of Mary (and Elizabeth) which unmistakably depicts a lace-edged veil.

Berthold of Regensburg

A 13th Century German Clergyman

You may busy yourselves with your veils, 

you twitch them thither; 

you gild them here and there with gold thread, 

and spend thereon all your time and trouble.

You will spend a good six-months work on a single veil which is sinful 

great travail - and all that men may praise thy dress.

This lets us know that decorated veils were definitely a thing, at least in the 13th century, and probably not uncommon.

In fact, there is a great deal of documentary and iconographic evidence that women in the Middle Ages regularly covered their heads. Muzzarelli, in her article, The Paradoxical Story of the Veil in the Middle Ages, notes, "Sumptuary laws testify to a woman’s obligation to cover her head, preachers dedicated entire sermons to the same subject and iconographical sources confirm it for females of all social conditions."

Sumptuary Laws may provide proof of the wearing of veils. An investigation of sumptuary laws regarding veils reveals restriction about who can wear them, what they can be made of, and how much they can cost depending on what country and when. For example, the 1363 English Sumptuary Law states that the wives and daughters of grooms and servants were not to wear veils above twelve pence in value and the wives and daughters of craftsmen and yeomen were not to wear silk veils.(Silverman /  Tindall)

I have a confession - I like bling; not gaudy, not blinding-in-your-face bling, but subtle, clean, and elegant bling. I love that decorative element that you may not even realize is what caught your attention. I also disclaim here this is solely my taste and opinion and is in no way a comment or statement on anyone else's love or dislike of anything.

While doing research in order to create a class on decorated veils, I discovered Oya - Turkish Needle Lace. I became fascinated.

Also, it is very persona-appropriate for Aliyah to wear such embellished veils which were common during the Middle Ages.(Muzzarelli) In brief, she was born in France and moved to the Holy Land in the later half of the 13th century, an area with a history of needle lace.

Oya - A Language in Lace

The history of Oya is somewhat difficult both to research and to document for the following reasons:

1 - Natural fibers degrade over time;

2 - It is a history of women; taught by one generation of women to the next;

3 - It is primarily from an area of the world where women have been historically insignificant while conquest, suppression, and destruction went hand in hand with history, especially the Armenian Genocide of 1915 during WWI; and

4 - It is not just one thing, in one form, specific to one time and one place.

What is Oya?

Oya, also known as Turkish lace or needle lace has a complex history. Oya, is the Turkish term for a decorative edging or embellishment for garments and other cloth articles that has been made since antiquity (Wetzel) created by working a thread or threads, usually of silk for special items or cotton for every-day items, into a pattern of knots to create a “lace.” 

There are four major types of oya: 

1 - Needle made oya (Turkish: ığne oyası)

2 - Crochet oya (T: tıg oyası)

3 - Tatting  oya (T: mekik oyası)

4 - Hairpin oya.

These various techniques are often combined and additional items, such as beads, sequins and paillettes are used to create different effects. (TRC Leiden) The ığne oyası is the historically traditional method.

Textile crafts originally were created to fulfill the most basic of needs: protecting from the natural elements, covering the body, storing produce and goods, decorating homes, and the  embellishing of these goods, to beautify.(Ergen)

Throughout its history, in addition to edgings on head scarves, undergarments, and household items, the art of oya has been used to created doilies and other larger textiles. In all cases, the lace is worked with needle and thread, developing row upon row of knots into intricate designs.

Where Did Oya Originate?

The short answer is Turkey. However, that’s not quite the whole answer.

Oya is not unique to Turkey. Credit for its origin is blurred, but evidence for its existence is wide spread along trade routes. It is also found “in Greece, Cyprus, Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Bulgaria, Armenia, Israel, and the historical Palestine region. Known variously as oya, Rodi lace, -Smyrna stitch, bibilla or bebilla, kombo velonya, Nazareth lace, kene, chebka, or Armenian lace.”(Wetzel)

It is often stated by researchers and artisans alike that “lace and embroidery were first introduced into Europe from Asia Minor;” however, there is no evidence to identify a specific time or place.  

In her book "Armenian Needlelace and Embroidery," Alice Odian Kasparian says “the knowledge of lacemaking was probably carried to Europe by the returning Crusaders [c. 1097-1270]. (p. 27)

When Was Oya First Made?

It is, however, possible that needle lace actually existed even earlier as evidenced by the Stele of the Scribe Tarhunpiyas (Fig 1 - Forgotten Kingdoms (louvre.fr). 

The Hittite empire, a great rival power of ancient Egypt, ruled over Anatolia and held sway over the Levant until about 1200 BC and gave rise to Neo-Hittite and Aramean kingdoms in modern-day Turkey and Syria. Note the decorated edge on Tarhunpiyas’s mother’s veil.

Kasparian is of the opinion Armenia must be the real home of this needle art. She cites four archaeological finds as evidence (p. 35) shown in Figures 2-4. 

Figure 2 is A gold brooch found in the province of Vaspouragan (Berlin Museum).

Figure 3 is an ornament similar to the Vaspouragan brooch. It is a silver ornament found in Karmir-Blur depicting a woman in a lace-edged head scarf (Historical Museum in Erevan)

Figure 4 is a statuette of the goddess Arubaini, consort of the god Khaldi. It was repeatedly bought by private collectors of antiquities, and in 1936 it got into the Historical Museum of Armenia. The figurine may have originally been discovered on the shores of Lake Van

https://dic.academic.ru/dic.nsf/ruwiki/287603 (Accessed 05/25/22)

The fourth find, a silver brooch found in Toprak-Kale (Berlin Museum) is not pictured.

Each of these finds is about 3000 years old and shows women in fine clothing with lace edges on their veil cloths. 

Armenian copper needles, for example, which date to around 7,000 BCE, mark the development of metal technology and would certainly be useful in the production of fine knots.(Homer)

While it is thought by some that this unique form of lace and beading may have spread from 12th century Anatolia to Greece and from there to the rest of Europe via Italy, in other parts of the world it is believed “. . . that oya, and in particular needle-made oya, is a descendant of Italian embroidered laces, notably Venetian  needlepoint lace. For several hundreds of years, from about 1500 onwards, there were close social and mercantile links between Istanbul  and Venice and from there with other European and Ottoman cities. It is known that lace was traded during this period.” (TRC Leiden)

However, it is difficult, if not impossible, to say where this knotty technique was first used.

Fig 1

Fig 2

Fig 3

Fig 4

Detail of Fig 4

Why?

Head scarves with decorated edges can be traced back to ancient celebrations of Pagan deities. In  "Armenian Needlelace and Embroidery," Alice Odian Kasparian describes the activities of Vartaavar which became associated with Ascension Day after the acceptance of Christianity in the 4th century CE. Young maidens would participate wearing silk head scarves edged with lace flowers and birds they created for themselves. These veils are called aklorik because “the aklor (rooster) was the symbol of happiness and health” was a favored motif.(p. 24)

The importance of the headdress for Turkish women is expressed in a proverb as “first head, then meal and then work, after waking up.” (Nas)  Headdresses and scarves, prayer and funeral head coverings, undergarments, outer garments, the edges of towels and napkins and as a decorative element in many other places were decorated with various kinds of oya. In the Aegean region even men’s headdresses were decked with layers of oya. Silk was most often reserved for items for special occasions and cotton yarns were used to make oya for daily wear.(TCF) 

Head coverings were not the only articles of clothing decorated by oya. 

"Needlework virtually festooned female court costumes of the Ottoman Empire (1299-1922): Garments were made from handwoven silk brocades bearing patterns of small flowers and leaves. Leather slippers, trouser hems, and jacket fronts displayed lavish floral embroidery. In addition, intricate needle-lace flowers known as oya (from ancient Greek words for hem and edging) decorated blouse necklines and cuffs as well as the edges of head coverings. Small needle-lace motifs sometimes formed a tiara or coronet topping a scarf or fez. Horsehair (later, wire) stiffened the tiny flowers, some of which were accented with pearls." (Krager)

Speaking in Knots

Although some scholars do not support the idea of symbolic meaning to oya motifs, Taciser Onuk’s extensive study of oya as a Professor of Art History, Ankara, Turkey, does indeed supports the idea of needle lace as a means of communication. “A new bride might signal her happiness by making and wearing green oya, her unhappiness by making and wearing yellow. Burdock shapes would tell her mother-in-law, ‘Do not stick to me like a thorn.’ ”(Wilson)

A few basic design elements are common throughout Mediterranean region; each culture has embraced them into its own tradition and patterns. Designs that represent aspects of the natural world, such as Mount Ararat, sunrise, carnations, honeysuckles, tulips (Anatolia is the source of the original tulips bred by the Dutch into modern tulip varieties), almonds, and chili peppers are classic examples. 

“Chili peppers have a special place in the Turkish language of flowers: Because a newly married woman was not allowed to speak without permission in her husband’s presence, she communicated the state of her marital relationship by the oya on her headscarf; chili peppers indicated the heat of anger toward her husband.”(Wetzel) Or passion? (Ergen)

De historia stirpium commentarii insignes (Notable commentaries on the history of plants), by Leonhart Fuchs and first published in 1542, describes new and exotic plants as well as plants that were purely medicinal. The inclusion of the chilli pepper, one of the New World plants which were unknown in Europe and Asia until the early 1500s is evidence to support the use of this motif during the Middle Ages, as the chili pepper became quite popular and well known in various regional cuisines. According to Michael Krondl, in The Taste of Conquest, it is likely Spanish Jews took chilies to the Eastern Mediterranean when they fled the Inquisition. 

"The ornamented headdress provides a way of expressing social status, economic power, and the level of craft skill of its wearer. Styles of headdress may also reflect the emotions of the wearer through the choice of fabric and colour."(Nas)

In an interview several years ago for the New Jersey Arts Council, Master Oya maker, Ylvia Asal, from Giresun, Turkey, told how “the women who hand-stitch it reveal how they are feeling with the embellishment of a particular flower or the edging of a distinctive ornamental pattern.”(Nerbak) The women would create their own language in the motifs of their lace indicating “I'm hoping to get married,” “I'm unhappy with my husband,” or “I'm still mourning my loss.” Her state of mind regarding familial life would be communicated creatively through the art of Oya.(Nerbak and Nishida)

“Within the textile crafts of Turkey, it sits in equal place alongside kilims, carpets, knitting, and embroidery. It is admired, collected, used, and made, reflecting the skills of the women who have continued this three-dimensional embroidery art for many centuries, passing down designs from mother to daughter through demonstration rather than documentation.”(Ergen)

An Observation

After almost five years of research on this topic I have to agree with Marina Scott from “Making,” who says, 

I have begun to notice a pattern. Almost all articles mention these crafts have non-European origins. That they most likely or almost certainly developed in Arabian, African or Asian countries. This fact is almost always stated in 1 or 2 sentences, and then there is an immediate shift to all things European. Once the shift has happened, there are more detailed dates, names, and places. Frequently credit is given to Europeans for making these things popular, ignoring the fact that many of these skills were developed, refined, and used for hundreds if not thousands of years before they were "discovered" by Europeans. It is very difficult to find information in detail outside of Europe on these topics. I wonder what has been lost, taken, or hidden away from the people who are the true developers of these crafts. I wonder how much more rich the story would be if it was told in full.

This sentiment was stated also by Patricia Hickman in her Master’s Thesis where she states, “'Lace as an art form is strangely enough purely European; the successful efforts of other countries are few,' according to Christa Mayer from the Art Institute of Chicago. When considering the wonder of lace outside of her boundaries, that comment seems singularly and peculiarly Western."

As stated at the start, the history of Oya has not been easy to research or document because it was made of cotton or silk, both of which are natural fibers that rapidly degrade over time; it is a verbal and hands-on history of women from an area of the world women are not well-respected or represented; and is not just one thing, in one form, specific to one time and one place.

Hickman tells of a rather interesting endeavor from the 1940s.

. . . as recorded in the Kütahya Museum Library, in western Turkey, an attempt was made to gather together a few old women who could separate a stack of oya into piles labeled "very old," "old," and "new." Memories responding to museum preserved objects. If another group of women were gathered together representing a broader ethnic and religious diversity – Turks, Greeks, Cypriots, Armenians, Arabs, Albanians, and Yugoslavs, there would be even more separate piles made. Oya, called by different names elsewhere, was certainly constructed by women beyond Turkey's present boundaries. The Ottoman empire which spread outward represented a time of giving and absorbing traditions, of trade. This study is not historical, focusing on accurate dating or geographical precision. It is not anthropological with comparative data. Though the thesis is entitled "Turkish Oya," it is a personal, visual response to more than a specific textile technique or achievement. What seems important is that oya speaks of time, of all time rather than of its present moment or an earlier moment of existence.

Oya Motif Examples

Some common motif examples of the special language of Oya from Frances Egen’s article, Oya – Turkish Needle Lace.

Grass / Meadow

The wearer wishes to convey a feeling of harmonious relations – as contented as flowers blowing in the breeze in a spring meadow.

Peppers

Worn to indicate a bitter relationship leaving a bad taste in the mouth or strong passion.


Leaves

States a desire for a long life full of wisdom.

Hyacinth

Symbols of hope, love, and virginity.

Wheel of Fortune

Tiny Wild Flowers 

A symbol of returning to the earth,

used by older women.

Bells or beads were often added to ward off evil spirits and to warn of difficult people in your midst.

Extant Oya

Woman’s Uçetek Entari or Three-Skirt Robe -  c. 1850-1920, Balkans or Anatolia. Made of silk; embroidered with couching of laid metallic thread wrapped around silk; metallic sequins. https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/86570

Detail of Front Edge

Detail of Collar

Detail of sleeve

Ottoman Embroidered Piece and

Detail of Oya on Edge (Below)

The images below are of a 16th century Italian garment. While the decoration does appear to be needlework, it does not resemble Oya and perhaps could be considered embroidery rather than a form of lace.

Smock - Italian 16th C and two close-up details

https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/80005193?img=2

Veils Made by Me

These two veils were made to be part of the prize selections for a Service Challenge Raffle at It Takes My Child to Raze a Village (2019).

White silk embroidered chain stitch on blue silk chiffon with pearls and gold beads decorating the edge.

My version of a pepper. Red silk and white pearls on white chiffon.

This veil was made as part of Pentamere's gift of a Turkish trouseau for Duchess Katryn. It has a hand-rolled hem and is white silk on white silk with 24 K plated glass beads. The Oya pattern is a half garland of 6 flowers with 8 beads (in two rows) supporting. Approximately 36 hours of work.

Close-up Detail

This veil was made for Baroness Zubaidah on the occasion of her stepping down from the position of Territorial Baroness of Andelcrag. It was a pleasure and an honor to create this for her.

The veil is 36"x36" white haboti silk. The oya is also silk.I chose to use a linked mountain pattern and created pansies using three 24K gold plated glass seed beads on alternating peaks  with an unadorned glass "pearl" on the other peaks. The faces of the pansies represent all the people she has touched with her service and kindness. Each corner of the veil is embellished with a tassel. Approximately 40 hours.

Upon receiving the above veil, Baroness Zubaidah asked for a scarf/veil to take as a gift for a friend at her upcoming trip to Turkey. The veil at the right (detail image far right) is a royal blue chiffon silk with gold silk oya, fresh water pearl and 24K gold plated glass seed beads that I call Mountain Vineyard (representing hospitality and prosperity). Since this was for a non-SCA person, only one long edge was beaded and the other long edge was just decorated with oya. Approximately 20 hours.

The veil took just over 20 hours to complete .

These two pictures are of a veil made for HRM AnneMarie during her AS 57 reign. She is not fond of the heaviness of beaded veils. I call this delicate and light white silk on silk with glass beads  Dragon's Scales and Treasures. I was honored that she donned this veil for the Court at which I was made a Baroness of Their Court after serving five years as the Territorial Baroness of the Barony of North Woods in the Middle Kingdom.

- 560 foundation units (~ 2250 stitches)

- 3655 decorative stitches comprising:

- 280 treasures - bead clusters

(~ 850 glass beads)

- 280 dragon scales 

(~ 2250 stitches)

As has been done throughout history by the women who practiced  and still practice this craft, I have created and named my own pattern for this oya edged veil - Climb Every Mountain.

The pattern is made of three oya triangles (mountains) of blue (5 knot base), gold (6 knot base), and purple (7 knot base), increasing in size, each topped with a glass pearl. There are clusters of three 24K gilded glass seed beads scattered between them and silk tassels hand-made of the same three colors at each corner.

During every lifetime there are moments of trial and moments of triumph. Climb Every Mountain represents the many and varying challenges and obstacles of life by the oya triangles of different color and size (because life is ever changing – the highs and lows of living, if you will). The pearls at the peaks and the gold beads in the valleys are treasures that represent the value of life’s lessons and wisdom learned along the way.

Entered in the 2023 Middle Kingdom A&S Competition: Top Score